This week Isabella had her 9-month well visit to the pediatrician. We brought her in the day before her scheduled appointment, because she had filled seven diapers in nine hours. Turned out she wasn’t dehydrated: good news. Slight fever, major diaper rash, super diarrhea, all of which tend to equal unidentifiable stomach bug. We learned that the purple Desitin is the one that helps and the new, improved blue (the one we had) wasn’t worth shit, because it does not waterproof your baby like a good deck stain. Following is the conversation following her scheduled appointment.
(Allow a little poetic license to capture the anxiety produced by the results.)
“Your baby’s doing good, Daddy,” said her mother.
“Good?”
“She was above average in almost all the categories,” she said. “There wasn’t an ‘excel’ category. But she was high normal in most of the categories of the questionnaire.”
“Most?”
“There was one that she had trouble with.”
“Wait a minute,” I said. “What do you mean there wasn’t an excel category? You mean it was only average and below average?”
“Normal, High Normal, and Not Yet—which I liked. Not Yet.”
“There wasn’t an above normal?”
“No, just high normal.”
“But this is America,” I said, confused. “We can’t do anything without proving we’re better than the next guy.”
“Well, this was a pediatrician’s office. They’re holding off on that. They don’t worry so much about comparisons.”
I had to disagree. From our first visit, our baby was dropped in a boil of every other baby that ever lived. We were given statistics: percentages, digressions from the mean. Reasons to compare. And worry.

bell curves: breaking hearts from birth to death
“But she was high normal in everything?” I asked.
“Right…”
“Except what?”
“Except…”
“What? Go ahead.”
“She was high normal in everything, but she’s not putting Cheerios in a bottle yet.”
“You filled out a questionnaire?”
“Right.”
“And they asked you that question—is she putting Cheerios in a bottle?”
“Yes.”
This had been a concern of mine for about two weeks, and her mother knew it. .
“She’s not putting things in things yet,” I said.
“Right.”
“Should she be?”
“Well…she could be. The doctor said that it would be exceptional if she was.”
There was that word: exceptional.
“So she’s not exceptional.”
“She was exceptional in everything else.”
“She was high normal,” I corrected.
“That’s really good, though.”
I processed.
“Her head was off the charts,” her mother said, with something like a laugh.
“Her head…” Another thing we’d worried about from the very first visit.
On the first visit, her weight was forty-forth percentile, her height was forty-eighth, and her head size was in the ninety-sixth percentile.
“Ninety-six,” I’d said to the doctor, alarm bells ringing. “Is that bad?” He looked like a cross between Doogie Howser and the young-looking lawyer on The Good Wife. In fact, he looked exactly like the young-looking lawyer on The Good Wife. Saying he also looked like Doogie Howser is gratuitous.
He said, “A large head can be something to worry about, but I’m not worried.”
This sounded to me the equivalent of, “Ketchup is red, but I don’t think it’s red.”
I’d been worried about her head size ever since. I was looking at pictures we’d already taken and noticing just how big her head really was. One made me think of the profile of the alien in Alien without the multiple dripping mouths.
“What do you mean ‘off the charts’?” I asked her mother now.
“A hundred and five percent or something.”
I’d hoped it would go down. It had gone up.
“But don’t worry,” she said. “He said it’s the shape of her head that’s causing it. Some people just have bigger heads. He asked if her mom or dad had a big head.”
I didn’t know whether I had a big head.
“I was sitting right in front of him!” she said. “I figured he could tell me whether or not I had a big head!”
“I don’t know if we have big heads,” I said.
“I don’t either.”
“But he’s not worried.”
“No, he’s not worried. He said it’s the shape of her head, like I said. And you know I’ve always thought the shape of her head was beautiful.”
“Okay, fine,” I said. “But the Cheerios in a bottle.”
“Right.”
“I’ve been worrying about that.” I’d been trying to get her to put plastic shapes in a red bucket. So far, she was good at taking the shapes out of the bucket. Dumping them on the floor. I was trying to get her to build, to stack. To create, not destroy. It wasn’t working. She wasn’t Michelangelo. She was an American company.
“I told him that,” she said. “I also told him about you putting the plastic rings on her ankles and how she has trouble getting them off and how you were concerned that it might be a problem.”
“And what did he say?” I was hoping he didn’t say “child abuse.”
“He said he didn’t think it was a problem. He said that if she could get the rings off her ankle, that would be exceptional.”
I sighed. That word again. Another near-miss.
It is hard when you think of your child as exceptional a lot of the time, only to realize that the hard, cold numbers tell a more measured story. She also hadn’t written a concerto yet.
It wouldn’t occur to the numbers to hold that against her.
I hated quantification, how it made everything less. Reduced it to something flat, and hard, and cold. Like employee reviews, where the point was to stuff you back down in a box of perceived mediocrity, so you wouldn’t complain or feel slighted the next time they took advantage of you. They convinced you you deserved it.
Worldly balance sheets left no room for magic, space to dream and be something more. Pixar films were supposed to take care of that.
It was the curse of Muggle-dom, to put it in Potter-ese.
“So what does it mean that she’s having trouble putting things in things?” I asked. “What is it testing?”
“It’s categorized under Problem Solving.”
“Problem solving.” I thought about that. Something occurred to me. “Wait a minute. How is it a problem that the Cheerios aren’t in the bottle? And why is it Cheerios? She hasn’t even seen Cheerios. Maybe it’s an indication of spiritual advancement. She understands that the Cheerios don’t have to be in the bottle. Not being in the bottle is not a problem.”
“I can’t answer that.”
But I was lying to myself. I remembered the drills I’d administered with the bucket and the plastic shapes, the rings around her ankles. It wasn’t quite Louis Gossett, Jr. making Richard Gere do sit-ups till he wept in An Officer and a Gentleman: “I GOT NOWHERE ELSE TA GO!” But it was the first taste of competition I’d had on her behalf.
On my behalf. For her.
In my mind I was already buying the Cheerios and the containers, mapping out her training.
At some point my mother developed a rather democratic theory of comparison, saying that all kids catch up to each other in time. You might be ahead or behind at a given point, but it would all even out.
And yet, as Americans or just simply humans we still thrilled at every indication of advanced, of specialness, of better. Of exceptional. Every sign of a future model, a future college football star. I developed early and had wide shoulders in seventh grade, and everyone I met told me future football coaches were going to salivate over me. My mother was right: everyone caught up. Coaches did not salivate over me.
“Our sweetie is advanced,” her mother placated me. “Don’t worry.”
I’d promised myself I wasn’t going to care about that. I wasn’t going to apply pressure, or risk ever feeling disappointed. I was going to try not to compare. “But someone in your class got an A,” I imagined myself saying. “Why wasn’t it you?” It made me sick.
Now, suddenly, roaring up: my inner tiger mother.
My mom has another expression she likes:
I just want to live in a house by the side of the road and be a friend to man.
Even the world seemed to laugh–or snarl–at this concept now. I just want to live in a big house in a rich suburb and be a star admired by all. Call it the Simon Cowelling of our nation.
Was it genetic, her head size, head shape? Did I have a big head? I didn’t know. But I had the sneaky suspicion that if I wanted to measure it, I was going to have to take it out of my ass first.
And keep on taking it out, since the world probably wouldn’t.
That said, I still didn’t see unbottled Cheerios as much of a problem. My daughter must take after me on that.